The house specialty
The Killer Ribs.
The reason the sign says what it says: baby back ribs cooked low and slow since 1986 - full racks, half racks and combos at both locations, with deals twice a week.
Ribs in Nutley Nov 2025 menu
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Full BBQ Rack with coleslaw, garlic bread & choice of fries or baked potato | 28.95 |
| Half BBQ Rack | 22.95 |
| Half BBQ Chicken | 18.95 |
| Half BBQ Ribs & Chicken Combo | 29.95 |
Ribs & BBQ in Rutherford current web menu
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Full Rack with cornbread, coleslaw & fries or potato | 24.75 |
| 1/2 Rack | 20.75 |
| 1/2 BBQ Chicken | 15.95 |
| Smoked Pulled Pork | 1/2 lb 14.95 · 1 lb 20.95 |
| Smoked Brisket | 1/2 lb 14.95 · 1 lb 22.95 |
| Brisket Burger 1/2 lb Angus blended with burnt ends of house-smoked brisket | 18.95 |
Rib deals & trays
| Deal | Where |
|---|---|
| Funday Monday full rack for the price of a half rack | Nutley |
| Tuesday Ribs $2.00 off full rack ribs | Rutherford |
| Catering trays 1/2 tray (4 racks) 89.95 · full tray (8 racks) 169.95 | Catering |
Prices as published by Jim Dandy’s; subject to change without notice.
Good to know
Frequently asked.
What comes with a rack of ribs?
In Nutley, racks come with coleslaw, garlic bread and your choice of fries or a baked potato. In Rutherford, they come with cornbread, coleslaw and fries or potato.
When are the rib deals?
Funday Monday in Nutley gets you a full rack for the price of a half rack. Tuesday in Rutherford takes $2.00 off full racks. Coupons can't be combined with these offers.
Can I get ribs catered?
Yes - BBQ rib trays come as a half tray of 4 racks (89.95) or a full tray of 8 racks (169.95), plus pulled pork, BBQ chicken and sides. Call 973-661-2222.
Why 'Killer Ribs'?
It's been on the sign since 1986 - baby back ribs cooked low and slow until they fall off the bone. Voted Top 5 for best ribs in the county.
Come hungry. Leave happy.
Nutley 973-661-2222 · Rutherford 201-896-2224 · open for lunch & dinner 7 days a week.