Trailblazin' burgers
Burgers with a reputation.
Half-pound Angus done the roadhouse way - Taylor ham on the Wally, burnt-end brisket blended into Rutherford's Brisket Burger, and sliders four at a time.
Trailblazin’ Burgers 1/4 lb / 1/2 lb Angus
| Burger | Price |
|---|---|
| Hamburger | 6.00 / 8.45 |
| Cheeseburger cheddar, swiss, American, pepper jack or mozzarella | 6.50 / 8.95 |
| Cheddar-Bacon | 7.50 / 9.95 |
| 1/2 lb. Wally Taylor ham & cheese | 10.70 |
| 1/2 lb. Gourmet lettuce, tomato, raw onion, cheddar, bacon & mushroom | 10.70 |
| 1/2 lb. BBQ Bacon Cheese | 12.95 |
| 1/2 lb. Black Jack pepper jack & bacon | 12.95 |
| 1/2 lb. Wild Buffalo mozzarella, buffalo sauce, side of bleu | 12.95 |
| 1/2 lb. TexMex cheddar & mozzarella, jalapeños, onions, tomatoes | 12.95 |
| Sliders (4) buffalo chicken, cheeseburger, hamburger, pulled pork w/ cheese or Philly cheesesteak | 15.95 |
| Turkey / Veggie Burger | 7.70 / 8.20 |
Make any burger a platter with fries & coleslaw for +$4.50. Rutherford adds a Beyond Burger (9.95) and the Brisket Burger — half-pound Angus blended with burnt ends of house-smoked brisket (18.95, with fries).
Nutley prices from the Nov-2025 menu; Rutherford items from the current web menu. Subject to change.
Good to know
Frequently asked.
How big are the burgers?
Quarter-pound or half-pound of 100% Angus beef - specialty burgers like the Wally, Gourmet, Black Jack, Wild Buffalo and TexMex run half-pound.
Is there a non-beef burger?
Yes - turkey and veggie burgers at both locations, and Rutherford also carries the plant-based Beyond Burger.
What's the Brisket Burger?
A Rutherford special: half-pound Angus beef blended with burnt ends of Jim Dandy's own house-smoked brisket, served with fries.
Can I make it a meal?
Any burger becomes a platter with fries and coleslaw for $4.50 more. Kids' burgers come with fries and a fountain drink.
Come hungry. Leave happy.
Nutley 973-661-2222 · Rutherford 201-896-2224 · open for lunch & dinner 7 days a week.